Apparently, Najib’s house arrest did not help win more seats for Umno in the Malacca state elections held on Nov 14. Umno’s seat count remained at 18 with its Barisan Nasional (BN) partners MCA winning two seats and MIC winning one seat, bringing the total to 21, the same number of seats it won in 2021.
The percentage of Malay voters who voted for Umno, however, rose dramatically from 49% in 2021 to 84% (New Voting Realities Post-Malacca Polls by Bridget Welsh. Malaysiakini, Nov 15). Whether that was due to the Najib house arrest factor or BN’s alliance with Perikatan Nasional (PN) is difficult to differentiate.
It may have had some effect, but not what Umno had hoped for that a house arrest for the former PM would draw out stronger support for it.
Thus the Najib factor, it seems, may have lost its currency for Umno in reviving the party, and especially now, following the declassification of the minutes of the Pardons Board’s decision to give a conditional pardon to Najib comprising a RM50 million fine and continuation of his jail term under a house arrest.
The board’s minutes raises constitutional issues that now overshadow the Najib factor for which the pardon was sought.
The declassified minutes showed that the King, Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar, granted Najib a house arrest despite objections from Attorney-General Dusuki Mokhtar, with Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh, concurring with Dusuki. (Declassified: Agong wanted house arrest for Najib despite objections. Malaysiakini, Nov 18).
According to the Malaysiakini report, Dusuki had told the board there was no legal basis for a house arrest in the federal constitution. The report also said that the King had ordered Yeoh to sign the conditional pardon order.
Constitutionally, the King has the prerogative to grant a pardon. The huge public debate that followed, however, sought clarity as to whether that prerogative meant two things: Firstly, constitutionally, can the King make a decision overriding the advice given to him? The constitution clearly states the King acts on the advice of the PM and the minister, in this instance, acts as the PM’s representative. Secondly, can the King issue an order that the AG has advised is not legal, which, therefore, the government can’t implement because it is illegal?
The debate continues but the PM’s silence is most noticeable.
In the event an illegal order is given, what can and should the government do?
Dusuki, made his stand clear. Yeoh was ordered to sign an order the AG has said has no legal basis. Should she have signed it?
MPs take an oath to uphold the federal constitution. When they become ministers and faced with an order to sign off an illegal course of action, should they buckle or should they refuse and stand the ground since the government can’t enforce an illegal order?
In this case, Yeoh could have respectfully told the king she can’t go against the oath she took and sign an order that the government has no basis to follow through, and that she would leave the meeting and take the issue to the PM who then must advice the King on the legal course of action.
It would have preempted the government from implementing an order without a legal basis, and this debacle, embarrassing to both the King and the government, would have been avoided.
Perhaps, Yeoh did not have the full backing of the PM to assert the government’s obligation for constitutional compliance. Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, after all, formed his administration on a royal mandate — not the mandate of the people. That would make it difficult for the government to NOT comply with a royal order.
A PM who understands our government as a constitutional monarchy and a constitutional parliamentary democracy will never put the government in a position where it has to fulfill an illegal order.
Ultimately, the PM is responsible and he must face the consequences of putting the government in this compromised state where it has to implement an order the AG has advised has no legal basis in the constitution.
The point is that the government is under oath to uphold the constitution and it is the PM’s responsibility to ensure that the government upholds it.
This PM must explain to the people why he didn’t.